I fell for APB: Reloaded and Rogue Company. APB was lauded for it’s customization and open world cops and robbers situation, but fell flat graphically after GTA V came out and hasn’t offered much new.

Rogue Company, IMO, had legs but it never caught on to the Twitch streamer following they wanted; Dr. Disrespect got into hot water a few years after launch and they had a whole map dedicated to him. Servers are still up but they announced no more updates, sadly.