Proprietary in the same way android is as far as I know. In that both have an open source foundation (AOSP and OpenHarmony respectively) but the final product built on top is proprietary.
Do you say the same of Microsoft? Or Apple? They both have their own OS. Huawei has 114,000 employees in Research and Development. Microsoft has 77,000. Apple has 166,000 in TOTAL and do not disclose how many are in R&D.
Huawei used AOSP, and Linux as a foundation for earlier versions of Harmony OS, but have since switched over to an entirely bespoke HongMeng kernel.
I’d personally rather it be FOSS but I’m still glad to have any sort of competition in the OS space. It should be normalized that all programs should just have to compile themselves into different versions for all OSes. The more OSes other than Windows we have the more companies will want this. I think Unity game engine already does this where it gives you a Linux, Mac, and Windows executable by default.
But it being closed source makes sense for its usecase too. The Chinese Government want this to be used in government there, just like Windows is in the US, and so they want the code locked down.
If I had to choose what OS to use my order of which ones I’d prefer probably goes:
GNU/Linux
FreeBSD
HarmonyOS
MacOS
Windows
I think the most important thing is that people realize Huawei is not making some Linux distro. They’re not a small or medium sized company. They’re a peer to Apple and Microsoft. An absolute behemoth that can support their own entirely in house software stack+ hardware ecosystem. That’s the real story here.
haram.
Proprietary in the same way android is as far as I know. In that both have an open source foundation (AOSP and OpenHarmony respectively) but the final product built on top is proprietary.
so not linux based ?
No
I wouldn’t be surprised if they also viaolating the GPL
Do you say the same of Microsoft? Or Apple? They both have their own OS. Huawei has 114,000 employees in Research and Development. Microsoft has 77,000. Apple has 166,000 in TOTAL and do not disclose how many are in R&D.
Huawei used AOSP, and Linux as a foundation for earlier versions of Harmony OS, but have since switched over to an entirely bespoke HongMeng kernel.
I’d personally rather it be FOSS but I’m still glad to have any sort of competition in the OS space. It should be normalized that all programs should just have to compile themselves into different versions for all OSes. The more OSes other than Windows we have the more companies will want this. I think Unity game engine already does this where it gives you a Linux, Mac, and Windows executable by default.
But it being closed source makes sense for its usecase too. The Chinese Government want this to be used in government there, just like Windows is in the US, and so they want the code locked down.
If I had to choose what OS to use my order of which ones I’d prefer probably goes:
GNU/Linux
FreeBSD
HarmonyOS
MacOS
Windows
I think the most important thing is that people realize Huawei is not making some Linux distro. They’re not a small or medium sized company. They’re a peer to Apple and Microsoft. An absolute behemoth that can support their own entirely in house software stack+ hardware ecosystem. That’s the real story here.
I have decided (for some time now) not to waste my time on none-copyleft software. not even MIT-licensed is good anymore.
I have been burned too many times by software becoming privatized after it was developed in “open source” way.
I understand china’s desire to have a homegrown echo-system that is not dependant on western tyranny, but that does not mean anything to me.
if china exported this it would be just like another apple. no thank you.
It is based on OpenHarmony which is open source under the Apache License https://gitee.com/openharmony/build/blob/master/LICENSE