From comp.os.minix, January 29, 1992
Andrew Tanenbaum argues that Linux’s monolithic kernel design is outdated. Torvalds responds, and an extraordinary debate about operating-system architecture follows.
Other sources:
From comp.os.minix, January 29, 1992
Andrew Tanenbaum argues that Linux’s monolithic kernel design is outdated. Torvalds responds, and an extraordinary debate about operating-system architecture follows.
Other sources:
The debate back then was already Tanenbaums fight against his own Minix’ obsolescence.
As I understand it Minix was quite popular among the scholars it was designed for.
But Tannenbaum wouldn’t make it “free”, although it did come for free with the book and you could get the source code for free. It was not licensed to enable further developments by users.
I stand by my claim that the problem was 100% the license. If Minix had used the GNU license, chances are pretty good that Minix could have become what Linux is today.
But of courser there are other factors, like how Linux worked with GNU, which was already a nearly finished OS that just lacked a kernel. So adding the 2 together and voila you had a complete OS.
Reading through the posts, I have to agree. It seemed like a lot of the folks wanted to turn MINIX into a full fledged OS, with all of the features which were emerging at the time. But Tanenbaum’s need to stay “the head surgeon” locked it into a paradigm that stopped progress. He couldn’t accept the idea that there would be 100 different flavors of MINIX, all distributed by different groups.
I also think that David Miller’s post near the end of the thread was spot on. MINIX wasn’t a fully fledged OS and was never meant to be one. Tanenbaum created an OS and book for his students to buy when they arrived in his class (as is tradition in academia). And he did such a good job of it that those students then turned around and tried to turn it into the OS Tanenbaum never intended it to be. And Tanenbaum resisted that. Had he been willing to let go of the OS and let it grow outside his control, we’d probably all be using derivatives of MINIX today. But he didn’t, so Torvalds was inspired to write Linux and threw it out into the ether. It was intended to be a full OS and was also available for people to make a 1000 different distributions of. Tanenbaum seemed convinced that this would cause chaos and would lead to an unsustainable mess. And he was kinda right, when someone says they use Linux today, you have to ask them which flavor before you can offer them any help. And we get all the flame wars and stereotypes which come with the various flavors (I use Arch, btw ;-) ). What I don’t think Tanenbaum, or any one else for that matter, foresaw was that this would all be OK. I also don’t think it would have worked before Al Gore “invented” the internet. By opening the door to the world and people everywhere, we now have a digital space where a thousand butchers with axes can come along and hack at a shared pig. But instead of complete chaos, the end result is a fantastic OS, with a lot of chaos around it. Like the chaos of life itself, there is a lot of beauty in that chaos.
Yes he did at the beginning, but didn’t he turn around but too little too late. Or maybe I remember it wrong?
In any case Minix was a wasted opportunity, but that’s OK, because now we have Linux. 😀
Indeed. Tanenbaum treated it more as an academic thing, not like a viable product. It had potential, but was totally wasted.
But by making that failure, he also failed the academic thing by not allowing users to make and share changes.
He saw it as a teaching tool, as context and to promote his book, which is a huge limitation on a teaching tool in a quickly changing environment.